Research, methods and collaboration

1998

Dust and the 1998 Supernova Evidence

Explore how the High-z team estimated dust effects from colour and light curves, and why its 1998 paper still treated extinction as a systematic uncertainty.

Original explanatory diagram: Dust and the 1998 Supernova Evidence

The short answer

When a distant supernova looks faint, what evidence helps tell dust and distance apart?

Read the evidence

What colour adds to brightness

A distance estimate combines several observations and assumptions.

Original comparison based on the cited records.
EvidencePotential meaningCheck
One faint measurementDistance or attenuation can explain itUse other bands and phases
Redder observed colourDust or intrinsic colour variationCompare with a calibrated light curve
Residual after fittingMay change a distance estimateTest the sample and alternative models

Two routes to a faint supernova

Distance spreads a sourceโ€™s light over a larger area. Intervening dust can also make an object look faint by absorbing or scattering part of that light. A single brightness measurement leaves these possibilities entangled. Ordinary dust tends to affect shorter visible wavelengths more strongly, so an object may also appear redder. But Type Ia supernovae can differ intrinsically in colour and luminosity. The useful observations therefore combine timing, colour and brightness. The challenge is to infer what the source would have looked like without extinction before turning the apparent brightness into a distance.

Sources for this section: [2] ยท [1]

The light curve supplies a reference

A light curve describes how brightness changes with time. Its shape helps standardise Type Ia supernova luminosities and helps constrain intrinsic colour. The 1998 paper compared distance estimates from two fitting methods. It describes correcting foreground Milky Way extinction and estimating an additional effect associated with host galaxies. A colour difference is not directly a dust measurement in isolation. It must be compared with the colour expected for a supernova at the relevant stage and interpreted through an assumed relationship between colour excess and extinction. Uncertainty in those choices belongs in the result.

Sources for this section: [2] ยท [1]

An invented two-band example

Suppose a calibrated light-curve model predicts a colour index of zero at a certain phase, and a distant supernova has a measured index of 0.10 magnitudes. In a classroom rule, assume every 0.10 magnitude of colour excess implies 0.30 magnitude of dimming in the band used for distance. An apparent dimming of 0.40 would leave 0.10 after that correction. If the source is intrinsically 0.05 magnitudes redder than predicted, the inferred dust contribution falls. These numbers are invented. They illustrate why the assumed intrinsic colour and the adopted extinction rule both influence a distance estimate.

Sources for this section: [2] ยท [1]

How the 1998 result was bounded

The paper analysed 16 distant supernovae together with 34 nearby ones. The distant group appeared roughly 10 to 15 percent farther away on average than the authorsโ€™ specified low-density model without a cosmological constant. That percentage is a model comparison, not a direct measurement of an acceleration percentage. The authors examined extinction alongside possible evolution, sample selection, local motions and other effects. Their analysis found that the tested systematic explanations did not reconcile the sample with the non-accelerating models they considered. This is more specific than saying every conceivable dust population was eliminated.

Sources for this section: [2]

What a reader should inspect

A useful reading separates the flux measurement from the correction and the final cosmological fit. Ask which bands were observed, what the light-curve comparison says about intrinsic differences and how much of the distance estimate changes under alternate treatments. A form of dust that attenuates several bands almost equally would be harder to diagnose by colour alone. Independent wavelength measurements and the way residuals change across redshift can then supply additional evidence. That is why a systematic test accompanies the discovery rather than becoming redundant once a fitted acceleration appears.

Sources for this section: [1] ยท [2]

Continue the chronology

Biography context

Explore United States through connected lives

Connected biographies

Researchers and collaborators

United StatesCulture

1969โ€“

Adam Riess

Observational cosmologistFollow Adam Riess from MIT and Harvard to the High-z Supernova Search Team, including his work on supernova colours, distance and cosmic expansion.Read biography
AustraliaCulture

1967โ€“

Brian Schmidt

Astronomer and research leaderTrace Brian Schmidt from Arizona and Harvard to Mount Stromlo, covering his Type II distance method and leadership of the High-z supernova team.Read biography
United StatesCulture

1959โ€“

Saul Perlmutter

Experimental cosmologistExplore Saul Perlmutterโ€™s career, the role of Carl Pennypacker and the Berkeley collaboration, and how scheduled searches made distant supernovae useful.Read biography

Quick answers

Common questions

Can colour alone give a dust correction?
It needs a reference intrinsic colour and an assumed extinction law.
Does the 10โ€“15 percent describe acceleration itself?
It describes mean distance differences from a specified comparison model.

Primary and institutional sources

How this history was checked

Dates, legal milestones and historical claims are checked against the official and institutional records below. This article was reviewed on 13 November 2026.

  1. Nobel Prize OutreachAdam Riess โ€” Nobel lecture
  2. Riess and colleagues, Astronomical Journal, 1998Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant