Architecture, collaboration and institutions

1833–1885

Two Building Phases of the Washington Monument

Compare Robert Mills’s Washington Monument proposal with its private construction phase and the publicly funded completion led by Thomas Lincoln Casey.

Original explanatory diagram for Two Building Phases of the Washington Monument

The short answer

The Washington Monument records two construction phases. Its surviving drawing, the unfinished early shaft and the federal completion identify different decisions and responsible organisations.

Compare the evidence

Decisions and their effects

The records describe different stages of the work.

Original comparison based on the cited records.
CountryDocumented decisionWhat it explains
Selected designMills proposed an obelisk and columned surroundShows which features were originally planned
First phasePrivate society stopped with a 152-foot shaftEstablishes what physically existed in 1854
Second phaseFederal work under Casey strengthened foundations and finished the shaftIdentifies the later organisation and engineer

The original proposal included more than the familiar shaft

The Library of Congress describes a design by Robert Mills in which an obelisk rose from a columned surround. The Washington National Monument Society chose the design in 1845. That drawing is a record of a proposal accepted by the sponsoring organisation. It gives a starting point for comparing the completed monument, whose familiar form consists of the shaft and its pointed top. A reader can identify the recognisable central feature and then ask which surrounding elements remained on paper. The comparison separates continuity of the main form from decisions about the rest of the design.

Sources for this section: [3] · [4] · [5]

Private construction produced a substantial unfinished shaft

The society raised money and began the monument with the cornerstone laid in 1848. By the end of the 1854 building season the unfinished shaft reached 152 feet according to the National Park Service timeline. The funds available to the society had run out. These details describe the state of the physical work at a specific moment, not a final judgment about the viability of the design. The incomplete shaft still existed on the site and became part of what engineers had to consider when making a new plan for completion.

Sources for this section: [6] · [5]

Federal authority created a second project

Congress authorised federal participation in 1876. Thomas Lincoln Casey was appointed engineer in charge in 1878 and directed work that included strengthening the existing foundation. The new phase had to bring an inherited structure into use rather than begin with an empty site. Financing, the organisation responsible and technical decisions all changed together. This makes the distinction between phases more substantial than a pause in the calendar. The resumed work depended on whether the shaft and foundation already built could form part of a completed monument under the new project.

Sources for this section: [6] · [5]

A completion and a dedication answer separate questions

The construction chronology records completion of the shaft in 1884 and dedication in 1885. A date can refer to the last work on a component, an institutional ceremony or the beginning of public use. The two dates help a reader place each event instead of trying to assign the whole work to one year. Mills’s original proposal, the private phase and Casey’s completion are similarly distinct. If an account is describing the designer, it can start with Mills. If it is explaining why the built object has its final form, the later federal work is part of that explanation.

Sources for this section: [6] · [4] · [5]

Compare the proposal with the inherited structure

Place the original design, the shaft as it stood in 1854 and the federal work in three columns. Record the columned surround under the proposal. Record the height of the unfinished shaft under the private phase. Under the public phase, note the foundation strengthening and the completed obelisk. The exercise gives a historical explanation that can be checked against three different records. It also makes the institutional collaboration visible across time, since a later group of public engineers had to decide how to complete work left by a private society and its architect.

Sources for this section: [3] · [4] · [6]

Biography context

Explore Washington, D.C., United States through connected lives

Connected biographies

People behind the work

United StatesCulture

1781–1855

Robert Mills

ArchitectRobert Mills designed monuments and public buildings, including the project that became the Washington Monument in Washington, D.C. Its construction continued after his death.Read biography

Quick answers

Common questions

What surrounded the obelisk in Mills’s design?
His proposal included a columned structure around the shaft that was not built in the final form.
Who oversaw the federal completion?
Thomas Lincoln Casey was appointed engineer in charge in 1878 and oversaw the work that finished the shaft.

Primary and institutional sources

How this history was checked

Dates, legal milestones and historical claims are checked against the official and institutional records below. This article was reviewed on 13 November 2026.

  1. Smithsonian Archives of American ArtRobert Mills family letters, biographical note
  2. Smithsonian National Museum of American History Archives CenterRecords of the Robert Mills Papers Project
  3. Library of Congress, Collecting MemoriesDesign of the National Washington Monument
  4. Library of Congress Prints and PhotographsDesign of the National Washington Monument in the City of Washington
  5. National Park ServiceHistory and Culture, Washington Monument
  6. National Park ServiceWashington Monument Construction Timeline