The short answer
The Roaring Lion is both a portrait and a story about making a portrait. Separating the sitting, the published image and particular physical prints explains how a brief encounter acquired a much longer public life.
Chronology
A timeline of the turning points
Speech and portrait sitting
Churchill addresses Canada’s Parliament and is photographed in the Speaker’s chamber.
A near-contemporary account
Solange Karsh sends the publisher an account explicitly identified as Yousuf’s notes.
Publication spreads the image
Saturday Night is followed by LIFE and The Illustrated London News.
A hotel substitution is discovered
The Château Laurier display is found to contain a forged replacement.
The particular print returns
Recovery in Italy and return to the hotel concern a physical print, not a lost negative.
Where and when did the sitting happen?
The Huntington dates the sitting to 30 December 1941 in Ottawa. Churchill had addressed Canada’s Parliament during a wartime North American visit. The Art Canada Institute identifies the Speaker’s chamber as the location of the photographic encounter.
The date belongs to the exposure, not automatically to every print bearing the image. The Huntington describes a signed print in its own collection, while an Alberta collection example is labelled as printed before 1972. These are separate objects sharing an earlier photographic source.
A prepared photograph, not an accidental snapshot
Karsh had arranged his camera and lights before Churchill arrived. His wider practice relied on large-format equipment, precise focus and carefully controlled illumination. A strong moment of expression was made useful by that preparation.
The usual contrast between a spontaneous moment and a staged portrait is therefore too simple. Something unplanned can happen inside a deliberately constructed setting. The photographer still chooses framing, exposure and which result is presented to an audience.
What is the evidence for the cigar story?
Karsh said he removed Churchill’s cigar and made the portrait as the irritated expression appeared. That is the photographer’s account, not a recording of every action in the room.
The ACI discussion points to Solange’s letter of the next day, which explicitly presents Yousuf’s notes rather than her independent eyewitness testimony. The anecdote is close to the event and central to the portrait’s history, but repeating it does not create a second independent witness.
Sources for this section: [2]
How a facial expression becomes a wartime symbol
The portrait’s stern pose was read as determination in wartime. The ACI records publication on the 10 January 1942 Saturday Night cover and subsequent reproduction in LIFE and The Illustrated London News.
Rombout’s broader analysis emphasizes the relationship between sitter, photographer and viewer. The public meaning is not confined to the moment in the room: captions, anecdotes, reproduction and historical circumstances help turn a particular expression into an image of national resolve.
The 2022 discovery and the 2024 return
Staff at Ottawa’s Château Laurier discovered that its displayed print had been replaced by a copy with a forged signature. Smithsonian’s 2024 reporting describes how the investigation traced the object to an Italian buyer who had not known it was stolen.
The ACI’s later account records the print’s return to the hotel in 2024. Neither event means the negative vanished, nor that every original print had been stolen. “Original” can describe an authorized physical print without establishing that it is the only surviving object carrying the image.
A portrait is not the sitter’s entire biography
The familiar expression can powerfully organize a viewer’s impression of Churchill. Karsh’s portrait tradition generally sought a concentrated, admiring image, with pose and setting supplying clues to stature and character.
That is an artistic achievement and a selective account. A reader still needs political history to examine the sitter’s decisions, contested record and wider life. The image, the anecdote and the biography answer related but different questions; none should silently stand in for the others.
Sources for this section: [4]
Continue the chronology
Related history guides
Biography context
Explore Ottawa, Ontario, Canada through connected lives
Yousuf Karsh’s life and working practice
Armenian origins, apprenticeship, Ottawa relationships and a wider portrait career.
Explore the biographiesSitterWinston Churchill beyond the portrait
Political biography rather than an entire life inferred from one expression.
Explore the biographiesConnected biographies
The photographer and the political subject

1908–2002
Yousuf Karsh
Portrait photographerYousuf Karsh was an Armenian Canadian photographer, born in the Ottoman Empire, whose carefully lit portraits and accounts of his sitters helped shape the public image of twentieth-century cultural and political figures.Read biography
1874–1965
Winston Churchill
British prime minister and writerWinston Churchill was British prime minister in 1940–1945 and 1951–1955. His resistance to Nazi Germany and wartime diplomacy were decisive parts of a much longer career involving political reversals, military failures, writing and imperial power.Read biographyQuick answers
Common questions
- Was The Roaring Lion photographed in London?
- No. Karsh photographed Churchill in Ottawa on 30 December 1941.
- Is the cigar anecdote independently proved by Solange’s letter?
- The letter preserves a near-contemporary account but explicitly calls it Yousuf’s notes. It is not presented as her separate eyewitness testimony.
- Was the Churchill negative stolen from the hotel?
- No. The theft concerned the Château Laurier’s particular display print. Other prints and the negative are distinct objects.
Primary and institutional sources
How this history was checked
Institutional object descriptions, ACI scholarship and the reported recovery were inspected. No physical archive examination is claimed. The illustration is a separately licensed photograph of Karsh, not an unlicensed Churchill print. This article was reviewed on 23 October 2026.
- The HuntingtonSigned print: sitting date, description and object identity
- Melissa Rombout / Art Canada InstituteChurchill: lighting preparation, Solange’s letter, publication and returned print
- Art Canada InstituteThe portrait sitting and large-format negatives
- Art Canada InstituteStorytelling, public identity and the admiring portrait tradition
- Julia Binswanger / SmithsonianSeptember 2024: theft, forged replacement and recovery in Italy
- Christopher Flach / Wikimedia CommonsPhotograph of Karsh with explicit CC BY-SA 4.0 grant